Maurice E Stucke ‘Reconsidering Competition’

This is a relatively old paper from 2011 by Maurice Stucke on a topic as straightforward as: “what is competition”. The paper has a fairly straightforward structure. In the first section, he reviews the concept of “competition”. It concludes that while there are multiple conceptions of competition, none prevails without qualification over the others. For example, some consider competition as an idealized end-state (such as static price competition under the economic model of perfect competition), while others view competition as a dynamic process. There is no easy way to arbitrate between these views. In the second section, he explores the reasons for this diversity of conceptions of competition, and concludes that they arise from differing  underlying assumptions regarding competitive processes. He tests this by relaxing the assumption of rationality of market participants and looking at its implications in section III. For my purposes here, the most interesting section is the first one, which  provides an overview of the various meanings…

Herbert Hovenkamp ‘The Rule of Reason’

This paper by Hovenkamp – available at https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=https://www.google.fr/&httpsredir=1&article=2780&context=faculty_scholarship – on the US rule of reason. It describes the historical background for the development of the rule of reason and its procedural requirements in US litigation.  It is short, very thorough, very opinionated, and should interesting to anyone interested on the basic underpinnings of competition law analysis (even if one is not a US antitrust lawyer). The paper covers a lot of ground, including: the trade-off between consumer and general welfare as antitrust standards;  different modes of analysis of antitrust infringements (e.g. per se, rule of reason and “quick look”); how to balance pro- and anti-competitive effects;  the shifting role of the per se prohibitions and rule of reason (i.e. a trend over the last 40 years towards reducing the role for per se rules as antitrust enforcement has focused more and more on the effect of individual business practices); and the main practical difficulties in applying the concepts underpinning a rule-of-reason analysis. While…