Jonathan Galloway ‘Securing the Legitimacy of Individual Sanctions in UK Competition Law’ (2017) World Competition 40(1) 121

This article – which you can find here – looks at attempts to impose individual sanctions for breaches of competition law in the UK. These sanctions include the recently amended criminal cartel offence – which can lead in imprisonment of up to five years – and the NCA’s power to apply for a competition disqualification order. Famously, the UK’s record in the enforcement of these sanctions is mixed (see below). To explain this state of affairs, the author identifies a tension between the economic theory of deterrence – which underpins the regime – and regulatory theory on the effectiveness sanctions – which, the author claims, has been ignored. The author points out that traditional deterrence theory relies on a combination of probability of detection and severity of punishment to create a perception of sufficiently high costs to deter wrongdoing. Yet when this leads to the imposition of very high penalties in order to counter a low probability of detection and…